Skip to content

NewsEuropean competitions

Carragher slams Bruno Fernandes: "a disgrace" after 4-1 defeat at Como

The former Liverpool defender criticised Manchester United's captain for questioning Michael Carrick's tactical choices. Carragher spoke on CBS Sports after the 4-1 defeat in the Champions League.

N1 Newsroom

Liga dos Campeões2 min read

Bruno Fernandes wearing the Manchester United shirt during a Premier League match at Old Trafford, December 2025.
Foto: AFC Bournemouth · CC BY 3.0 · Wikimedia CommonsCC BY 3.0

Jamie Carragher did not spare Bruno Fernandes. The former Liverpool defender, who works as a commentator for the American broadcaster CBS Sports, said the Manchester United captain was wrong to speak about the manager's choices after the 4-1 defeat at Como in the Champions League.

What Bruno Fernandes said

Speaking to TNT Sports, the Portuguese midfielder said it was a decision of the coaching staff not to press man-to-man and to leave space behind the defence. That, he argued, gave Como confidence.

Asked whether Carrick got the tactics wrong, he replied that this assessment was for the manager and the coaching staff, "not for me". He added that sometimes you have to be braver under pressure and risk a high press.

Bruno was substituted in the 67th minute. According to Sky Sports Italia, cited by Football Italia, he struck the bench when returning to the substitutes' bench.

Carragher's reaction

Carragher accepted that Carrick's season is not going well. But he defended the manager and said the captain's attitude is "bad" and not that of a United captain, according to ESPN and ABC.

The former England international also recalled the case of Lisandro Martínez, who the previous week criticised the club's structure over the transfer market. Carragher's quote was this:

"For Bruno Fernandes to do this is a disgrace, honestly."

The quote is a translation of what Carragher said in English on CBS Sports.

Carrick's response

At the press conference, Carrick responded to Bruno without naming him. He said the team pressed man-to-man in the second half and conceded a goal in that phase. He also said no system works if players do not run, forwards and backwards.

The manager described the performance as unacceptable and apologised to the fans who travelled to Italy. He said he had not yet thought about his future.

What is at stake in the dressing room

United have gone seven games without a win in all competitions. They have lost five of their 11 matches this season. Carrick signed a two-year contract in May, after leading the team to third place in the Premier League.

The case joins that of Martínez, who eventually apologised and started in the draw at Leeds. Two public criticisms in eight days, coming from a captain and an influential defender, increase the pressure on the manager. They also put Bruno at the centre of the debate about leadership in the squad.

The club had not publicly commented on the case in the sources consulted.

Automatically translated from Portuguese.

  • #Bruno Fernandes
  • #Michael Carrick
  • #Jamie Carragher
  • #Manchester United
  • #Liga dos Campeões

Related news

See all